R5Realty News and Notes

Market Snapshots and Commentary on Value and Quality of life along the former Main Line of the Pennsylvania Rail Road, up until recently called the R5 Line, and now officially known as the Paoli /Thorndale line. R5Realty runs from Center City Philadelphia through the walkable, Westward outlying Towns & Townships.

Wednesday, February 15, 2012

First-Time Narberth Home Buyer: Regrets Few Despite Realtor's Double-Dip

Every buyer is an entitled to an agent and since Buyer representation is free, why not have an agent in your corner? Before we began as an agents, Heather and I bought our first house - a cute Narberth cottage back in the late 1990s. Nearly everything related to the purchase, the sale, and the decade we resided there was pleasant. Like most folks who bought at the Millennium and then sold before the market imploded in 2008, we were and are still grateful that the cottage obtained a 50% increase in market value during our ownership.

Some things about that first, somewhat nerve-wracking transaction stand out in mind. (1) Shared Driveway. We swore we would never buy a house with a shared driveway based on the cottage experience. Sure enough, in 2009, we did buy a shared driveway twin, but this time we had a pre-existing relationship with our new neighbor, which helps gloss over any rough spots or tight squeezes. But we had no such platonic buffer with our shared driveway back at the cottage. At times, navigating the undivided blacktop was on par with tankers dueling in  the Strait of Hormuz. Not fun. In retrospect, a Survey and the addition of an innocuous, paved divider might have helped.

(2) Just because a home inspector has an alliterative name that is synonymous with thoroughness and toughness in these parts, doesn't mean he or she is the person for the job. On reputation and referral I hired a local "name" inspector more suited to 7-figure deals. True to his word, the house held up  But not so much the basement retaining wall that showed obvious signs of cracking and fatigue during the inspection. A complete home-buying neophyte at the time, I was gun shy about mentioning my concerns about the wall to the legendary inspector. Several years into ownership, the wall needed costly replacing. No big deal, but if it was obvious to me, how could a seasoned pro overlook a large crumbling wall affixed to a Tiny Cottage? Lessons learned: (a)There are no bad questions during a home inspection. (b) Don't hire a tank to deconstruct an ant hill.

(3) And finally, I learned a bit about Dual Agency - which is when the same Real Estate agent represents both the Buyer and the Seller... Our Agent at the time (our first agent ever), was also the Listing Agent for the Cottage that we purchased. She was the one who brought the cottage to our attention. Now I had once read about extenuating circumstances when One agent represents both Buyer and Seller, so I asked our agent if there was anything unusual about her handling both sides of the deal... She indicated it happens all the time and presented nothing unusual.

Common sense - the kind that should have alerted me to the potential pitfalls of a narrow, shared driveway and a cracked retaining wall, should have also led me to understand that One Person (One Agent), cannot be a confidential advocate for Buyer and Seller at the same time. Ideally, my Realtor would have proactively pointed this out. She was aware we were naive, uncoached, first-time buyers  in need of an advocate dedicated to protecting our interests, without the baggage of a pre-existing fiduciary duty to the other side of the deal.

It's possible laws and disclosures were not as stringent in the 1990s as they are in the quasi Post-Apocalyptic world of Real Estate Regs that currently govern agents like myself.. In today's world, Realtors are required to proactively inform consumers about potential conflicts of interests. As it is, I can't say I was overtly harmed by allowing the Sellers' agent to also perform as my Buyers' agent. The deal we made was pretty much win-win, but I would have liked someone in my corner during the negotiations that came up at settlement. If my neutered agent had been on my team and not neutral, perhaps I would have made a few extra bucks.
In the long run, the money was and is is irrelevant.  We got the house, enjoyed it, maintained it, and sold it for a good price, but I believe it was a breach of trust and exploitation of my naivete to have been counseled to act without an advocate in my corner.


Bottom Line:   There are 3 primary types of Representation available to consumers of real estate services:
1- Seller Agency (Realtor works only on Sellers behalf),
2- Buyer Agency (Realtor works free on Buyers behalf), 
3- Dual Agency (Realtor represents both sides in a NEUTRAL fashion) and is the advocate for Nobody so as to avoid conflict of interest.

If both parties are savvy and sophisticated and able to fend for themselves, Dual Agency isn't such a bad thing. Heck, since the agent is making a Double Commission (!), dual agency can be an opportunity for Seller and Buyer to neogitate some money back. But in a situation where either party is counting on someone to actively protect their interests and provide exclusive counsel, Dual Agency is not a good look.

When out home shopping, you can call the Listing Agent on the Lawn sign. Hear what he or she has to say as they may know things about the house other agents don't.  But when it comes time to perform serious diligence or make an offer, Buyers are entitled to independent free representation and ought to get it. By the same token, Sellers have a right and interest in seeing their Listing agent does not double dip and dilute efforts on sellers behalf.

Friday, January 13, 2012

End of 2011 Home Prices in Narberth & Lower Merion

November and December's Homes Sold Under a Million Lower Merion and Narberth

Street AddressTownSold ForBedsBathsSq. Ft.Asked
205 Greenfield TerArdmore$130,000 511,350$145,000
114 Elm AveArdmore$203,500 31.11,275$214,900
328 E Spring AveArdmore$236,000 211,006$249,500
123 Sutton RdArdmore$250,000 321,860$250,000
316 Locust AveArdmore$296,000 42.11,800$299,900
147 Cricket AveArdmore$381,500 42.22,652$375,000
125 Grandview RdArdmore$402,500 52.12,334$389,900
38 Chestnut AveBala Cynwyd$280,000 31.11.109$285,000
115 David RdBala Cynwyd$315,000 322,274$385,000
5 Heckamore RdBala Cynwyd$381,000 33.12,440$375,000
107 Grasmere RdBala Cynwyd$400,000 44.12,778$495,000
222 Ebenezer AveBala Cynwyd$470,000 533,100$479,900
21 Penarth RdBala Cynwyd$475,000 43.12,314$495,000
104 Bryn Mawr AveBala Cynwyd$765,000 53.14,738$775,000
201 Oak Hill RdBala Cynwyd$800,000 54.14,007$865,000
158 Maple AveBala Cynwyd$310,000 31.11,533$319,000
639 Old Gulph RdBryn Mawr$451,050 333,042$549,000
1101 Beech RdBryn Mawr$655,000 44.13,103$675,000
801 Edwin LnBryn Mawr$914,500 64.14,166$1,099,000
208 River RdGladwyne$250,000 11952$350,000
522 Consh. State RdGladwyne$778,000 43.14,133$819,000
231 Righters Mill RdGladwyne$830,000 43.13,198$900,000
1551 Lafayette RdGladwyne$957,500 67.15,959$1,049,000
1115 Youngsford RdGladwyne$985,000 34.13,644$1,095,000
207 Haverford RdWynnewood$240,000 32.13,152$270,000
531 Glenwood RdMerion $355,000 42.11,576$399,500
327 Hamilton RdMerion $542,000 42.22,400$599,000
265 Forrest RdMerion $900,000 52.13,378$899,000
236 Forrest AveNarberth$200,000 52.11,742$200,000
514 N Essex AveNarberth$327,500 311,802$350,000
333 Merion AveNarberth$355,000 41.11,794$369,000
203 Barrie RdNarberth$375,000 321,692$385,000
213 Price AveNarberth$377,000 41.11,780$375,000
224 Avon RdNarberth$425,000 411,675$439,000
14 Hansen CtNarberth$425,000 32.12,480$430,000
226 Hampden AveNarberth$555,000 53.12,194$579,000
540 Sprague RdPenn Valley$515,000 42.13,321$569,000
1125 Hollow RdPenn Valley$540,000 44.13,337$595,000
1213 Centennial RdPenn Valley$560,000 42.12,388$600,000
1319 Centennial RdPenn Valley$572,000 42.13,022$599,999
206 Fairview RdPenn Valley$715,000 42.12,606$799,000
308 Sprague CirPenn Valley$775,000 43.24,139$840,000
403 Fairview RdPenn Valley$863,000 43.13,416$899,000
400 Saybrook RdVillanova$565,000 443,845$600,000
1309 Valley RdVillanova$596,854 53.13,988$599,000
1415 Kyneton RdVillanova$730,000 23.13,100$765,000
1157 Brynlawn RdVillanova$942,000 43.13,260$979,000
230 Harrogate RdWynnewood$322,000 321,836$339,900
272 Henley RdWynnewood$346,000 321,561$350,000
1605 Brookhaven RdWynnewood$386,500 32.11,572$385,000
1358 Garden RdWynnewood$516,250 53.12,912$530,000

New Narberth Home: Thinking Outside the Box





 At Left: Garage & In-Law Suite, Center is Main House. Right is Retained Element of Original Farm House.

   
  This brand new modular, pre-fab home is in rapid progress of being completed on a gorgeous 1.1 acre lot at 233 Righters Mill Rd in Narberth/Penn Valley. New owners are relocating from Art Museum area and plan to enjoy the wonderful Elementary school just down the street. R5Realty plans to post updates photos but rest-assured, this is no glorified trailer park.  Extensive planning and consideration went into the $500,000 purchase of the property and the well-worn and now razed 75-year-old farmhouse. 
 Neighbors are fotunate to welcome new owners, who are constructing just their own custom-planned 5,000+ sq ft., single-family dwelling, progressively designed and sensibly situated to retain the distinctive quality of the neighborhood and bucolic landscape. Scranton's Simplex Industries and Orion General Contracting began assembling the prefabricated modular sections on January 11. 

The project is expected to take about two months to complete, but you would never know it given the alacrity with which  a huge crane hoisted and swung modules into place on the pre-poured foundation. In addition to the main structure, the home will have a garage and mother-in-law suite attached via breezeway. A small portion of the original farmhouse has been salvaged and owner plan to creatively incorporate it into/onto the main home. This sensitivity and vision is representative of the project as a whole, which utilizes a variety of green concepts efficiencies.
 Lots More R5 Realty Photos of the Project

Cranes lift and place modules forming the Main House. Plans for incorporating original remnant are TBD.

.